MILWAUKEE — In a bold move aimed at breaking open a case that has gripped the nation, Attorney Michael Hupy, President of Milwaukee Crime Stoppers, has announced a $100,000 reward for information leading to an arrest in the abduction of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie.
Guthrie was forcibly taken from her Arizona home and reported missing on February 1. Recently released doorbell camera footage shows a masked, armed perpetrator outside her residence, an unsettling image that has intensified concern and fueled nationwide calls for answers. Weeks later, her whereabouts remain unknown.
Determined to generate new leads and reinvigorate the investigation, Attorney Hupy has stepped forward to double the previously offered reward amount, sending a clear message: someone knows something.
“This is an 84-year-old woman who was taken from her home,” said Attorney Hupy. “Time matters. I believe more could have been done sooner, and we cannot afford to wait. By increasing the reward and leveraging the anonymous tip system through Crime Stoppers, we are giving people a safe, confidential way to do the right thing.”
Milwaukee Crime Stoppers operates a fully anonymous tip platform designed to remove fear and barriers that often prevent witnesses from coming forward. Historically, anonymous tip systems have proven critical in generating leads that law enforcement might not otherwise receive, particularly in high-profile or sensitive cases.
Attorney Hupy, senior partner of Hupy and Abraham, S.C., a Midwest personal injury law firm with 11 offices across Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa, has long combined his legal career with public safety advocacy. He has secured multi-million $ results for clients, including a $22 million award for an injured child, but he says efforts like this go beyond the courtroom.
“Justice isn’t only about verdicts,” Hupy said. “It’s about protecting communities and standing up when something isn’t right.”
Under his leadership, Milwaukee Crime Stoppers has helped generate anonymous tips leading to arrests, fugitive recoveries, and justice for victims and families. The newly announced $100,000 reward represents one of the most significant private efforts aimed at advancing this case and underscores his continued commitment to accountability and public safety.
Anyone with information about Nancy Guthrie’s abduction is urged to come forward. Tips are completely anonymous.
How to Submit a Tip
• Call: (520)882-7463
• Online: https://www.p3tips.com/tipform.aspx?ID=259
About Hupy and Abraham, S.C.
Founded in 1969 in Milwaukee, Hupy and Abraham, S.C. is a nationally recognized personal injury law firm with a proven track record of success. The firm has recovered Billions of Dollars on behalf of more than 80,000 clients, earning a reputation for powerful advocacy and meaningful results for injury victims.
With 11 offices across Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa, Hupy and Abraham represents clients in a wide range of personal injury matters, including car and motorcycle accidents, truck accidents, wrongful death, and pharmaceutical and medical device litigation.
Beyond its legal achievements, the firm is widely known for its strong commitment to the community, having donated more than $1 Million back to the community in support of safety initiatives and charitable causes throughout the Midwest.
The firm has earned more than 2,500 five-star Google reviews and received 250+ awards and recognitions for excellence in legal advocacy.
For more information, visit www.hupy.com
